I’ve been experimenting with comment aggregators BackType and CoComment. Each has something I like, and each has apparent shortcomings.
I like BackType because it’s well-presented, has tools for locating and following authors, a nice alerts feature (gigs, and reviews, for example) is easy to set up. But it doesn’t do such a good job of locating and providing feeds. For example, it hasn’t found any of Joanna Geary’s recent comments, even though it links to her website just fine, and it doesn’t find so many of the authors I’ve suggested to it. So I’m not getting much out of BackType. I have been experimenting with CoComment, partly because of a rapid response to a post by Chris Unitt, but finding it also less than satisfactory. It does update more rapidly than BackType, but it also produces spurious updates. Today coComment sent the same ‘update’ notice 9 times between 10:00 and 12:10, even though the conversation hadn’t changed since last Thursday.

I went to the CoComment help forum to ask about it, but found that there’s no way to add a new topic, nor respond to an existing one. Big mystery there. How did other people get their topics and comments listed?
The Help forum looks like this:

There are no ‘Add Topic’ buttons on this page, nor anything else that functions as such.
So how did these existing topics get there?
And in case you’re wondering, there’s nothing in any of the existing topics that allows me to add a reply.

I tried viewing the forums in four other browsers, including Opera and IE. Same thing everywhere. Looks like the coComment forums are busted. So I sent a message to them using their textarea contact form. That was oh, 12 hours ago. Maybe they’ll get back to me in a day or so.
So it’s still a very mixed bag for these two comment aggregators. Think I’ll check out co.mments and BlogFlux’s Commentful.
Sphere: Related Content
Tagged backtype, cocomment, comment aggregators